Here's my reranking of the scents in the regular line.

*Love*
1) Banana Smoothie
2) Frozen Daiquiri

*Like*
3) CBH
4) Perfect Peach (except for the 3-in-1 b/c that's off)

*Just Not My Type*
5) Iced Tea Twist
6) Melon Cooler
7) Orange Freeze

*Yuck!*
8) Frosting Forever
9) Pecan Passion
10) Alluring Apple

LOVE AND NEED AND HOARDE:
CBH
ITT
Orange Freeze

LIKE ENOUGH TO GET SOMETHING IN:
Banana Smoothie
Frozen Daquiri
Melon Cooler

NICE BUT NOT FOR ME:
Forever Frosting
Pecan Passion
Alluring Apple

NEVER:
Perfect Peach

Here are my rankings:

Iced Tea Twist
CBH
Orange Freeze
Frozen Daiquiri
Banana Smoothie
Frosting Forever
Alluring Apple
Melon Cooler
Pecan Passion
Perfect Peach

From the spring kits Birthday Blowout is my favourite, I also like Pop!Cheers!Clink! but it can smell a bit boozy,
and from the limited editions Beyond Berry is my favourite. Sunset Mango is a close second.

I just voted, and my favorites are Iced Tea Twist, Pop Cheers Clink, and Sunset Mango.

Summer Temptations:
BEYOND BERRY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Sunset Mango and Island Coconut are way at the bottom.

I haven't had a chance to smell any of the new scents. My BBW is closed until May 30. The up side is: it will be a flagship when it reopens so it's well worth the minor inconvenience!

Lovey, it'll be well worth the wait since you're getting a flagship store. I am green with envy.

Now after having smelled all the Temptations scents, out of all of them my number 1 favourite is still Orange Freeze. I thought Beyond Berry was going to change that, but unfortunately, the lotion smells really weird out of the bottle, and I couldn't get passed that scent.

You're right, Fryl! So I'm practicing patience! I could drive to the other store but I've just been too busy to do that.

I'm hopeful that the Coconut one will be nice. I LOVE Coconut!

Here's my ranking; I bought all the 3-in-1's except Perfect Peach because I'm not really a peach fan in general. I got Frozen Daiquiri thinking it would grow on me, but it really hasn't.

Love
Iced Tea Twist - It feels like I'm showering with lemon iced tea. There are no words.
Melon Cooler
Orange Freeze
Cinnamon Bun Heaven - I'm rating the first incarnation of CBH, not sure if there's a big difference.
Pecan Passion - I was very surprised by this, I didn't expect to like it nearly as much as I do. I'll definitely be dusting this off when the weather gets cooler!


Like
Frosting Forever
Alluring Apple - This is good, but it smells exactly like PA Apple to me. Nice, but nothing new. I prefer Spiced Apple Rapture to this.
Banana Smoothie - I was hoping this would be more like TBS's Banana line, which was straight-up banana.


Just Not My Type
Frozen Daiquiri - (Maybe it's just me, but this smells really plasticy and chemically. Haven't actually showered with it yet.)
Perfect Peach

Here are my rankings for the summer scents.

*Not Bad, But Not For Me*
1) Sunset Mango
2) Island Coconut

*Yuck!*
3) Beyond Berry

1. melon cooler-love it 2. island coconut yuck-banana smoothie and sunset mango.

I updated the poll to add some new fall scents. Apple Fizz is in the scent selections b/c there haven't been any other kits so far this fall.

My favorite fall scent is Simply Divine Cherry Pie. Everything else is just .

I updated the poll to include the holiday scents. I haven't gotten the chance to smell the 2 mint combos, but I have an idea of what my rankings are. I'll post a more accurate ranking once I've gotten to sniff those two.

Like:
Dreamy Chocolate Mint (I'm really anticipating this one. )
Glittery Gumdrop
Twisted Peppermint

Not So Fond Of:
Sassy Strawberry Mint (this sounds to me)
Sugar & Spice

I would say the Simply Divine Cherry Pie is my favorite, followed closely by Glittery Gumdrop in 3rd. I'm so over Pecan Pie Paradise unfortunately!

Orange Freeze is still my favourite of all the scents they've come out with so far.

Other scents I like but don't love (in bodycare):
Twisted Peppermint and SDCP.

Of the holiday scents so far, I prefer Glittery Gumdrops.
Just for fun, here are my top four all-time Temptations scents, in no particular order:
-Pumpkin Pie Paradise
-Sunset Mango
-Iced Tea Twist
-Cinnamon Bun Heaven

I really love Vanilla Ice Cream, too, but since it's not available in all forms then I don't really count it.

I would have to say Simply Divine Cherry Pie followed by Glittery Gumdrop.

Of the holiday scents so far my favorite is still TP!!! I like Glittery Gumdrop, but I still have to use it in the shower to really see.
My top 5 (in no particular order)
Banana Smoothie
Twisted Peppermint
Crazy Caramel Corn
Simply Divine Cherry Pie
Cinnamon Bun Heaven

My favorites are:

Sunset Mango
Frosting Forever
Glittery Gumdrop
Pecan Passion

Looking forward to the Chocolate Mint also--