Since the new line of Temptations has now made an appearance in mini 3-in-1 form, it's now time to decide our rankings of the scents.

I'll refrain from voting now since I haven't gotten a chance to smell 2 of the scents.

Question:
What's your favorite Temptations scent from the full sized spring product line?

Choices:
Alluring Apple
Banana Smoothie
Cinnamon Bun Heaven
Frosting Forever
Frozen Daiquiri
Iced Tea Twist
Melon Cooler
Orange Freeze
Pecan Passion
Perfect Peach

Question:
What's your favorite Temptations scent from the spring kits?

Choices:
Birthday Blowout
Blueberry Velvet
Buttercream Dream
Chocolate Chocolate Chip
Chocolate Escape
Pineapple Chiffon
Pop Cheers Clink
Raspberry Taffyta
Salty Caramel Ice Cream

Question:
What's your favorite Temptations scent from the summer line?

Choices:
Beyond Berry
Island Coconut
Sunset Mango

Question:
What's your favorite Temptations scent from the fall line?

Choices:
Apple Fizz
Pumpkin Pie Paradise
Simply Divine Cherry Pie
Vanilla Ice Cream

Question:
What's your favorite Temptations scent from the holiday line?

Choices:
Dreamy Chocolate Mint
Glittery Gumdrop
Sassy Strawberry Mint
Sugar & Spice
Twisted Peppermint

 

Right now my favourite has to be Banana Smoothie!
I can't wait to smell Buttercream Dream though, I have a feeling I may like that one better but we shall see.

I don't want to vote just yet since Buttercream Dream and the lotions haven't been released, but my rankings thus far are:
1. Iced Tea Twist
2. Cinnamon Bun Heaven
3. Banana Smoothie
4. Melon Cooler

The other scents aren't even on my radar.

I haven't smelled the Buttercream or CBH yet, but so far my rankings are:

1. Melon Cooler
2. Iced Tea Twist

The others were nothing special to me.

I voted for Iced Tea Twist -

My rankings are:
1. Iced Tea Twist
2. Melon Cooler
3. Orange Freeze

The rest were pretty blah...

1banana
2 daq
3 orange.

is it me or does the new frozen daq smell
like bubble gum?

1) Iced Tea Twist
2) Melon Cooler
3) Cinnamon Bun Heaven
4) Orange Freeze
5) Banana Smoothie
6) Frozen Daquiri
7) Perfect Peach
8) Alluring Apple
9) Pecan Passion
10) *Buttercream Dream yet to sniff*

I voted for Banana Smoothie as my favorite, although I warn you this is subject to change!!
Even though I don't especially care for the scent, I almost voted for Iced Tea Twist just because it is so original and "out of the box" for BBW.

I don't know if I have an exact ranking, but I can categorize them:

LOVE:
Banana Smoothie

REALLY LIKE:
Alluring Apple
Perfect Peach
Cinnamon Bun Heaven

LIKE:
Orange Freeze
Melon Cooler
Pecan Passion

NOT BAD, BUT NOT FOR ME:
Iced Tea Twist
Frozen Daiquiri
??Buttercream Dream??

In the interest of fair play, here's a reranking, to include all the scents:

*Love*
1. Iced Tea Twist
2. Cinnamon Bun Heaven

*Like*
3. Banana Smoothie
4. Melon Cooler
5. Pecan Passion

*Meh...nothing special*
6. Perfect Peach
7. Orange Freeze
8. Frozen Daiquiri
9. Frosting Forever

*Gross*
10. Alluring Apple

I voted for Iced Tea Twist but I really like all of them except for Pecan Passion . Good thing I have 5 3in1 coupons.

This poll has been edited to include Frosting Forever & the spring kits. I'm sure there'll be a lot of voting going on once we see these on Mon.

I think I have my favorite scent from the regular scents figured out. And the winner is Banana Smoothie. The lotion is a sweet tropical banana scent & I've warmed up to the 3-in-1 a bit more.

I do love Frozen Daiquiri, but it's been around for awhile. On the other hand, I've been saying that BBW should make a banana scent pretty much since I've been a member of this board. And now I have my wish.

I got to smell Frosting Forever & it smelled kinda weak. It was better than VS Slice Of Heaven, but there was a little bit of a VBN note in it. I'll resniff it tomorrow & see if my opinion changes. If not, that 3-in-1 that I ordered is going back to the store.

Megan, I'm glad to hear that the banana lotion smells great. I might pass on the Frosting Forever lotion in favor of this, we'll see tomorrow.

Thanks for the review, Megan. I can't wait to sniff the Banana Smoothie. I'm in love with anything banana lately but it has been really difficult finding true banana scents. I'm also interested in sniffing the FF lotion. I hope it smells as good as Jaqua Pink Buttercream!

I got to sniff all the lotions today. I ended up getting Iced Tea Twist, CBH, and Banana Smoothie lotions. I smelled Frosting Forever and it smelled like a mix of plastic and VBN. Not so great.

I didn't get a chance to sniff any of the occasion kits items, but Blueberry Velvet looks the most interesting, and the Strawberry Syrup gloss looks so pretty!

I also updated my ratings in my earlier post.

Okay, now that I've sniffed all the Spring Temptations scents & ruminated a bit about them - - I've got some updated rankings:

1. Iced Tea Twist
2. Frosting Forever
3. Cinnamon Bun Heaven (this smells so much better than the prior version, imo)
4. Melon Cooler
5. Pecan Passion
6. Banana Smoothie
7. Alluring Apple
8. Frozen Daiquiri (I'm tired of this scent, so I don't like it as much as I used to )
9. Orange Freeze
10. Perfect Peach

(Of course, my rankings may change as I sniff and/or try them some more, but for now, this is how I rank 'em. )

Heres my new rankings:

1. Banana Smoothie
2. Frosting Forever
3. Cinnamon Bun Heaven
4. Frozen Daiquri
5. Orange Freeze
6. Perfect Peach
7. Melon Cooler
8. Alluring Apple
9. Iced Tea Twist
10. Pecan Passion

My favourite Temptations scent now is: Orange Freeze. I really don't care much at all for any of the other scents anymore. I do really like Banana Smoothie but it doesn't agree with me.

Here's my ranking of the kit scents.

*Scents I Like*
1) Raspberry Taffy-ta
2) Birthday Blowout
3) Chocolate Chocolate Chip & Chocolate Escape (tied)
4) Salty Caramel Ice Cream

*Not Bad, But Not For Me*
5) Pop Cheers Clink

*Yuck!*
6) Buttercream Dream
7) Blueberry Velvet
8) Pineapple Chiffon

Here is my ranking for the new Temptations scents!


Iced Tea Twist
Cinnamon Bun Heaven
Melon Cooler
Banana Smoothie
Pecan Passion
Perfect Peach
Orange Freeze


Frozen Daiquiri
Frosting Forever- this one smells okay in the bottle, but smelled yucky when I put it on me


"Too Many Animals, Too Few Homes, Save Lives, Neuter or Spay!"



Home-of-the-Furry-Friends