As some of you might have noticed I love anything marshmallow scented, so I was wondering:
What's your favorite Marshmallow scent??

I have tried many, here's some thoughts on them

Calgon Marshmallow -- I do like this but to me it smells more like the sugar on top of the marshmallows, also I think it has a fake smell to it.
Rate: 3/5


BBW Holiday Sweets Marshmallow Cream -- To me this smells more chocolate-y rather than marshmallow-y but it's still good, unfortunatly it was discontinued a long time ago so I'm not using mine often since I don't want to run out .
Rate: 4/5


IoE Sugar Me! Marshmallow -- I think this smells more like cookies with a marshmallow cream glaze, it's nice but not quite what I was looking for. Also I can't wear this often, it has this buttey scent to it that I can't stand, it gives me a headache when I smell it all day. I think this is better mixed or layered with other fragrances.
Rate: 2/5


Starring! The Romantic -- this one is not only marshmallow, the description is "Fluffy Marshmallows, White Cake, Toasted Marshmallows".
It is really yummy, not a pure white marshmallow smell more like a warm toasted scent, it almost has a cotton candy scent to it (you know how cotton candy smells like warm toasted sugar).
I really love this one, I could wear it every day and never get tired of it.
Rate: 5/5


Mad City Sue: Fresh Marshmallow -- Smells similar to Calgon Marshmallow, but this one is much lighter and a little sweeter. It's good paired with other scents (like in her triple treat scrub) but not the best on it's own.
Rate: 3/5


Jojoelle: Magnificent Marshmallow -- I have this on the way in an 5mL Parfume so I'll let you know how it is once it gets here


Heaven&Earth Essentials: Marshmallow Cream -- also have this on the way to me in a Hair Mist


I'm still looking for the perfect, non-toasted, fluffy white Marshmallow scent. Any input would be appreciated.

From that the scents you've posted, NgbsFL, I've only tried the first two.
I like Calgon Marshmallow.
I used to like the Holiday Sweets Marshmallow Cream, but not anymore so I gave both my containers away.
I like Sephora Marshmallow Fluff, but I don't think it smells like marshmallows. It's a hard scent to describe.
I know you're crazy about marshmallow scents, so I hope you find the ultimate one!

*I love Calgon Marshmallow. My mom stole my set from me, but I let her since it's one of the few B&B scents she likes.

*BBW Holiday Sweets Marshmallow I loved to death. I'm hoarding 2 tubs of it. It's whippy and chocolatey and I love it. It's also very long lasting.

*IOE Sugar Me! Marshmallow I haven't used enough to review. It's on the shelf for February.

*Sephora Marshmallow Fluff is nice, but I agree with Fryl in that it's not quite like a marshmallow....

My favorite is MCS's Fresh Marshmallow. I love this!

BBW Holiday Sweets by far.
I am hoarding 2 tubs also.


I also like the Calgon Marshmallow although it smells more like the POWDER on a marshmallow.
Rite Aid (formerly Brooks, Eckerd) and Walgreen's still have it on the shelves.

Not sure, but I think there was a Jaqua body butter that came in a marshmallow I've got stashed somewhere.

Of course VBN will work in a pinch. We used to call it 'The Marshmallow' when it first came out.

My vote----Calgon Marshmallow!

I second that, mardi!!

i really like cherriflip's marshmallow frosting i have some of this in a lotion love it! i also love urban decay marshmallow powder some one was selling a container of it for $5-! love it also! cool talk to you all later! anita