With fall coming up soon, I thought this would be an interesting poll.

Question:
What's your favourite pumpkin scent for body care?

Choices:
Perfect Autumn Pumpkin
Sweet Cinnamon Pumpkin
Pure Simplicity Pumpkin
Fall Temptations Pumpkin Pie Paradise

 

I love the PA Pumpkin scent but only in HFO form. I like SCP, but only in the room spray, and I like PPP the least.
I voted for PS Pumpkin because it's a very faint buttery pumpkin scent.

PA Pumpkin, hands down. It's the truest pumpkin scent I've come across in body care.
SCP is great in home fragrance but I can't stand it in body. PS Pumpkin I absolutely hate, and PPP is all right.
Other good pumpkin scents I've come across are Ulta's Cinnamon Pumpkin Pie and a brandless bodywash I got at WalMart for $0.24 after this last Christmas called Gingerbread Pumpkin. I bought four of them and mailed one off to Kimmer.

I like both the PS Pumpkin and Sweet Cinnomon Pumpkin the best. PPP is good and I like it but the 3-in-1 is a little strong to me. I like the PA Pumpkin in shower gel but I am glad I didnt get in lotion, that would be way too much. I hate the PA Pumpkin room spray so I dont think I would love it in HFOs. It made me

I will hold off on voting until I smell the Temptations stuff. Otherwise, I'd vote for SCP. I'm not crazy about PS or PA pumpkin.

I'm hoping to make it to the mall tomorrow, so I'll have to vote after that.

I'm not a pumpkin type of girl, but I have smelled various pumpkin items. I smelled SCP during this past sale & I thought it actually smelled decent in bodycare form. I actually haven't smelled that one in home fragrance form. Pumpkin Pie Paradise was quite bland. I'm sure I've smelled PA Pumpkin @ some pt., but I can't remember what it smells like. But for some reason I'm thinking I'd rank that one as better than Pumpkin Pie Paradise, but not as good as SCP.

I love love love the pure simplicity pumpkin body butter. it smells sooo good, but it's not too overly spicy like most of the other pumpkins are. i don't really like scp, ppp is okay, but seems a bit faint for me, PA pumpkin is best in home fragrance...pure simplicity hands down

I'm not a big fan of pumpkin scents but every once in a while I do like to use my PA Pumpkin. I tried the PPP today and didn't like it. So I guess my vote will be for the PA Pumpkin.

Edward, I love the PS Pumpkin Body Butter too.
It's not getting discontinued, right? I stocked up on it when it was introduced, so I don't think I need to get anymore, but I'd be crushed.

I think it'll be sticking around, Fryl...I hope so, it's soooo yummy

I voted for SCP. I love that scent, and it's a close "relative" to Winter Candy Apple as well.

OK, now that I've smelled them all, I voted for SCP.
After a re-sniff of PA, it ties for second with PPP. PS is third.

quote:

Originally posted by edward:
I think it'll be sticking around, Fryl...I hope so, it's soooo yummy

That's such a relief to hear. Thanks Edward.
I used some this morning, you're right, it's soooo yummy!!

quote:

Originally posted by Becky:
PA Pumpkin, hands down. It's the truest pumpkin scent I've come across in body care.
SCP is great in home fragrance but I can't stand it in body. PS Pumpkin I absolutely hate, and PPP is all right.
Other good pumpkin scents I've come across are Ulta's Cinnamon Pumpkin Pie and a brandless bodywash I got at WalMart for $0.24 after this last Christmas called Gingerbread Pumpkin. I bought four of them and mailed one off to Kimmer.

x 10. Thanks again Becky . I'll take every opportunity I can get to emphasize how yummy the Cinnamon Pumpkin Pie Moisturizing Souffle is. Simply delish!

I gave the Fall Temptations Pumpkin Pie Paradise another sniff today, and I must say I don't think it is as bad as I first thought. In fact, I like it better than the SCP body care stuff.

i do like the sweet cinnamon pumpkin,
i dont like just plain pumpkin for some
reason.it just makes it a little sweet.

Has anyone tried the Garden Botanika 'Pumpkin Ginger' line?

I received a catalog in the mail the other day. There is body butter, sugar scrub, body secum, gel and fragrance therapy (splash).

Garden Botanika is available at Ulta.


I have their ChocoLatte and Sweet Retreat stuff and it's rather expensive compared to BBW. Sweet Retreat is reminiscent of WVS with a touch of lemon and pineapple.

GB just came out with a Paraben Free Prickly Pear Jojoba line. Haven't opened the sample they sent me. However, I believe prickly pear is a cactus rather than a pear. This line is supposed to be free of mineral oil, petrolatum and sodium lauryl sulfate.

I gotta say that Pumpkin Pie Paradise is my favorite pumpkin scent. Sweet Cinnamon Pumpkin is a close second though.

My favorite pumpkin scent is Pure Simplicity Pumpkin!


HOTFF (SAVE ANIMALS LIVES NEUTER or SPAY)

Has the Pure Simplicity line been discontinued?