Since the Garden collection has now been revamped as Secret Garden, I thought it would be appropriate to have a new poll to discuss the latest generation of scents.

Obviously, I'm anticipating there being new future scents too. So this poll will be edited as needed.

Question:
What is your favorite scent from the basic Secret Garden collection?

Choices:
Amber Romance
Blossoming Romance
Endless Love
Love Spell
My Desire
Pear Glace
Pure Seduction
Romantic Wish
Strawberries & Champagne
Sweet Temptation
Vanilla Lace

Question:
What is your favorite scent from the Vanilla Dreams collection?

Choices:
Blackberry Bliss
Coconut Passion
Orange Blossom Dream

 

Here are my rankings.

*Love!*
Pure Seduction
Romantic Wish

*Like*
Blossoming Romance
Strawberries & Champagne
Vanilla Lace

*Nice, But Not For Me*
My Desire

*Get Rid Of These Now!*
Amber Romance
Endless Love
Love Spell
Pear Glace
Sweet Temptation

I voted for Vanilla Lace, I have loved this one since it first came out!!!
I have never smelled Amber Romance or Pure Seduction and on my coupon card I got, those smell really good, but I'm not sure if they are all blending and thats what I am smelling So I will have to check those out.

I really do love Vanilla Lace and Love Spell equally. Since VL got representation in the poll from Gizmo, my vote went with LS, which was the first Garden scent that I fell 100% in love with.

My rankings:

LOVE!
1. Love Spell
1. Vanilla Lace

Like:
2. Pear Glace
3. My Desire

Ick!
4. Amber Romance
5. Strawberries & Champagne
6. Midnight Mimosa

I can't recall the other scents well enough to even include them, besides Forbidden Fantasy, Passionate Kisses, and Pretty in Pink, all of which come back every SAS and all of which I like.

I voted for Blossoming Romance, which I just recently purchased. My niece and I love it. Love Spell is good too though.

My rankings! I really don't hate any of them. There are just some I like more than others.
LOVE:
*Romantic Wish!!!!!!!!!

Like:
*Endless Love
*Love Spell
*My Desire
*Pear Glace
*Vanilla Lace

Nice to have one item:
*Amber Romance
*Pure Seduction
*Blossoming Romance
*Strawberries and Champagne
*Sweet Temptation

My favorites are Sweet Temptation, Honeysuckle Belle, and Forbidden Fantasy.
I am not a big fan of Amber Romance.

Right now out of the current scents I'm only loving Blossoming Romance. The other scents are okay.
Strawberries & Champagne is still a favourite but I don't like it as much as I used to.

I'm not very crazy about any of the VSG scents, and I don't actually own any at the moment (gasp!). This is my breakdown:

Nice enough, but I can live without them:
Love Spell
Pear Glace
My Desire
Endless Love

Not for me, thanks:
Blossoming Romance
Amber Romance
Pure Seduction
Romantic Wish
Strawberries and Champagne
Sweet Temptation
Vanilla Lace

I edited the poll to include the new Vanilla Dreams collection. I haven't gotten a chance to sniff these yet, but so far it looks like Blackberry Bliss might have the most potential of the 3.

My favorites are Forbidden Fantasy, Blissful Moment, Pure Seduction, and Blossoming Romance in that order.

As far as the Vanilla Dreams line...Vanilla Coconut Passion HANDS DOWN is the best of the 3. It smells soooooo good...Like a coconut cream custard filling w/a hint of sugary vanilla!

Ugh...Out of the Vanilla Dreams VS collection, the only one I would have considered getting was the Orange Blossom. The Blackberry one smelled just like the old 2004 Passionberry and Coconut from BBW. It's a good scent, but I already have it. That Coconut one was a real dud, IMO.

Hope it's better luck next time on the LE stuff from VS....

I have to agree with Anan on this. I was at VS today and I personally didnt really care for any of them, the only one that was semi decent was the orange one, so needless to say I left empty handed

None of the new limited edition scents stood out to me. I was expecting to be in love with the Blackberry scent but it left me unimpressed. I may have to go back to VS to give these scents a second chance but right now I can't even vote for a favourite.

quote:

Originally posted by Anan:
Ugh...Out of the Vanilla Dreams VS collection, the only one I would have considered getting was the Orange Blossom. The Blackberry one smelled just like the old 2004 Passionberry and Coconut from BBW. It's a good scent, but I already have it. That Coconut one was a real dud, IMO.

Hope it's better luck next time on the LE stuff from VS....

Anan, i was trying to think what bbw product
the blackberry smelled like after sniffing
it today, and couldnt think of what it was.
but your right on the money, it does smell
like passionberry and coconut.

MY favorite Secret Garden Collection scent is- Pear Glace.

I haven't yet tried any scents from the Vanilla Dreams Collection!


I LOVE MEERKATS!


"Too Many Animals, Too Few Homes, Save Lives, Neuter or Spay!"



I-love-the-Meerkats-of-the-Kalahari
aka Home-of-the-Furry-Friends

I picked Amber Romance...

Please don't come at me with a wooden stake and a crucfix.

Glad to see Sweet Temptation is back in new packaging. Go Kiddie Tylenol...

quote:

Originally posted by Jeff:
I picked Amber Romance...

Please don't come at me with a wooden stake and a crucfix.

Glad to see Sweet Temptation is back in new packaging. Go Kiddie Tylenol...

lol

I LOOOOOVE Love Spell. It reminds me of warm evenings at the beach. Smells so sensual and alluring

I like blackberry bliss from the VD collection. Smells yummy

I am glad to see that my fave is in the lead! Go Amber Romance! I am wearing it right now!